- Instrument
- Supreme Federal Court, Themes 987 and 533
- Status
- Settled and final
- Next milestone
- Last reviewed
What the Court decided
Article 19 had made providers liable for third-party content only after a court order. Under the Court’s ruling, providers are, as a rule, jointly liable when they fail to remove unlawful content after private notice. A prior court order remains required in specific cases, including offences against honour. Paid, boosted content carries a rebuttable presumption of fault.
The judgment on the motions for clarification, on 17 June 2026, confirmed a closed list of serious offences and set 60 days, counted from the minutes of that judgment, for platforms to implement structural duty-of-care measures. The ruling applies from 5 August 2025, except for continuing conduct. The judgment on the merits was concluded on 26 June 2025, and the minutes for the related Theme 533 were published on 25 September 2026.
What it means for platforms
Notice handling, triage, escalation and audit trails are no longer a matter of internal policy. They are what a platform operating in Brazil must be able to evidence, and they are, in our view, the core of the content moderation opportunity.
Key dates
- 26 June 2025Judgment on the merits concluded.
- 5 August 2025Date from which the ruling applies.
- 17 June 2026Thesis finalised on the motions for clarification; 60-day implementation period set.
- 25 September 2026Minutes for Theme 533 published.
Primary sources
Related theses
Last reviewed .